Why easing control can make the season lighter
The holiday season is upon us once again. In this edition, I've tried to offer some more directly actionable content, rather than just information or opinion, and included links to some helpful books which I've found valuable, in case you want to discover more or need last-minute stocking fillers!
The holiday season has a way of compressing life.
In a short span of weeks, routines loosen, calendars fill, food changes, social dynamics intensify, and expectations quietly rise. We tell ourselves this is a time to slow down and enjoy, yet many people arrive at January feeling more depleted than restored.
Part of the tension comes from how we frame the holidays. We tend to treat them as a problem to be managed rather than a season to be lived. Exercise becomes something to “stay on top of.” Nutrition becomes something to “keep in check.” Family time becomes something to “get right," and relaxation becomes another task on the list.
There is a deeper question worth asking: Are we undermining rest, health, and enjoyment by trying too hard to optimize them?
The Long View: What Actually Matters for Health
One of the most helpful reframes during the holidays is zooming out.
Health is not shaped by a handful of meals or missed workouts. It is shaped by patterns that repeat over months and years. When we look at exercise, nutrition, and wellbeing through this lens, a short period of disruption loses much of its threat.
Think of it this way: What happens between New Year and Christmas matters far more than what happens between Christmas and New Year.
This perspective is consistent with long-term behavior change research and with the broader message found in books like Hidden Potential by Adam Grant, which emphasizes systems, character skills, and sustained environments over isolated acts of discipline. Progress is rarely derailed by pauses; it is derailed by rigid thinking that makes pauses feel like failure.
The holidays are not a test of consistency; they are a test of flexibility.
Exercise: From Control to Continuity
Exercise is often the first thing people worry about losing during the holidays. Normal schedules disappear. Gyms close or feel less appealing. Motivation dips.
The common response is to either double down (“I must keep everything the same”) or disengage completely (“I’ll start again in January”). Both approaches miss an opportunity.
The body does not require perfection. It requires continuity.
Continuity can look very different from routine. During the holidays, movement often works best when it becomes simpler and more forgiving:
- Walking instead of structured cardio
- Shorter sessions instead of longer ones
- Strength maintenance instead of progression
- Movement for regulation, not performance
This aligns well with principles discussed in endurance and resilience-focused training frameworks, including those outlined by Steve House in Training for the Uphill Athlete, where recovery, sustainability, and respect for context are treated as integral to performance rather than deviations from it.
Rest is not the opposite of training. It is part of it.
If the holidays provide a natural reduction in training load, that is not a problem to solve. It may be exactly what the body needs.
Nutrition: Eating Without the Moral Overlay
Food carries emotional weight at the best of times. During the holidays, that weight increases - excuse the pun.
Many people approach December with an underlying fear of “doing damage,” which often leads to a cycle of restraint, indulgence, guilt, and resolution. This cycle is far more disruptive than the food itself.
From a physiological perspective, occasional richer meals do not meaningfully alter long-term health outcomes. From a psychological perspective, however, attaching moral value to eating does.
A more stable approach is to treat holiday nutrition as different, not dangerous.
That means allowing festive foods without framing them as transgressions. It also means keeping a few gentle anchors in place. They might be:
- Eat until comfortably satisfied
- Include protein regularly
- Stay hydrated
- Notice how food feels, not just how it tastes
These are not rules. They are orientation points.
This way of thinking echoes themes found in Outlive by Peter Attia, where health is framed as a long game and short-term fluctuations are contextualized rather than catastrophized. The body is resilient. Metabolic health is cumulative.
Food during the holidays is not just fuel. It is memory, culture, and connection. When we try to strip that away in the name of optimization, we often lose something more important than nutritional precision.
Relationships, Emotional Load, and Energy Management
While exercise and nutrition get most of the attention, the most draining aspect of the holidays is often relational.
Family systems re-emerge. Old roles get replayed. Expectations go unspoken but strongly felt. There is pressure to show up, participate, and smooth things over.
This is where anxiety often creeps in, especially for people who care deeply about harmony and responsibility.
One of the most useful distinctions here is between effort and outcome. We can put effort into being thoughtful and present without guaranteeing that every interaction will feel good or meaningful.
In Dare to Lead, Brené Brown remind us that boundaries are not barriers to connection; they are what make sustainable connection possible. Saying no, leaving early, taking time alone, or opting out of certain traditions is not failure. It is self-respect.
Energy is finite. Spending it intentionally is a form of care, not selfishness.
The Anxiety of Making Things “Perfect”
There is a quiet paradox at the heart of the holiday season.
We want things to feel relaxed and joyful, so we try to make them relaxed and joyful. We plan, organize, schedule, and curate. In doing so, we often create the very tension we are trying to avoid.
Enjoyment does not respond well to force.
This idea shows up repeatedly in psychological research and in reflective works like Creativity, Inc. by Ed Catmull, where excessive control is shown to stifle the very outcomes it aims to produce. The same principle applies to rest and connection.
When we monitor our enjoyment too closely, we step out of experience and into evaluation. Presence gives way to performance.
The alternative is permission. Permission for the holidays to be uneven. Some moments will feel warm and connected. Others will feel awkward, boring, or tiring. None of this means we are doing it wrong.
A Kinder Definition of Success
What if success during the holidays were defined more gently?
Not by adherence to routines, but by adaptability. Not by perfect meals, but by attunement. Not by flawless gatherings, but by honesty about capacity.
In Learned Optimism, Martin Seligman reminds us that flexible interpretation and realistic expectations are shown to protect wellbeing far more effectively than forced positivity.
Optimism does not mean pretending everything is enjoyable. It means trusting that discomfort is temporary and that one season does not define the whole story.
Carrying This Forward
The holidays are not separate from life. They are part of it.
They offer a chance to practice a more humane relationship with health, one that values continuity over control and compassion over correction. If we can move, eat, connect, and rest in ways that are “good enough,” we often emerge more intact than if we had tried to do everything perfectly.
January does not require penance. It requires re-entry.
Perhaps the greatest marker of health is not how tightly we hold our routines, but how confidently we can loosen them occasionally without fear.
Do you find this content useful? Would you like to receive my newsletter version of this article with more actionable content?